Robbie’s is a marina first and has never pretended otherwise. The reason it’s on this site is everything that grew up around the docks: a bar that pours cold beer all afternoon, a restaurant with more seafood than you’ll get through, a row of shops, and the thing everyone actually comes for, which is paying a few dollars for a bucket of baitfish and hand-feeding tarpon the size of a Labrador off the end of the pier. The pelicans get whatever you drop.
The bar sits under a thatched roof with the Overseas Highway on one side and mangroves and open water on the other. Sand underfoot, water in every direction, most of the seating covered, so a summer squall is a pause and not an ending.
It works two ways. If you’re driving to or from Key West, it’s the lunch stop at mile marker 77.5 where you stretch your legs and feed something prehistoric. If you’re staying in Islamorada, it’s the afternoon you don’t plan and don’t regret.
Submitted by Mike Ostrander, who was on the stool. His report on the beer: cold. On the seafood: numerous. We’ll take it.
Thirsty for more? Dive into the Bum’s full guide to the best beach bars in Florida.