Named for the Taíno-Arawak word for “moonlight,” Karaya sits right on the sand at Shoal Bay West, which already puts it in the conversation for best beach setting in Anguilla. The husband-and-wife team behind the celebrated Veya and Sandbar bring the same obsessive attention to detail here: house-made pasta, locally caught fish, crudo brightened with orange oil, and a wine list deep enough to keep you busy all afternoon. The views toward St. Martin don’t hurt either.
